the good book corner

Manuscript help, book reviews and author interviews

We That Are Left by Clare Clark


“DENIQUE COELEM” is the  family motto of the Melvilles of Ellinghurst. Translated it means ‘heaven at last’.

Ellinghurst serves as the backdrop of Clare Clark’s period novel We That Are Left. With its sprawling lawns and gothic architecture, it symbolises the epitome of English aristocracy- the lifestyle, the glamour, the challenges and the failures. Centuries of history resides at Ellinghurst and adding to it, in early 1900s, are the young Melvilles – Theo, Phyllis and Jessica. Their family is dysfunctional but tradition keeps them bound together in their privileged world.

Oskar Grunewald is not a Melville, but Ellinghurst is a part of his and his mother’s lives. A frequent visitor, Oskar is fascinated by the house, especially the enormous library. Ignored by the other children, he spends all his time lost in books, finding companionship in numbers and the infinite laws of physics. Oblivious to how their destinies are entwines and how Ellinghurst will change their lives, the children all go their separate ways- Theo to the battlefront in France, Phyllis to excavate tombs in Egypt, Jessica to the glitzy London life and Oskar to Cambridge, to pursue his scientific dreams.

Theo Melville is killed in the Great War, demolishing the lives of the family left behind. The war changes everything and while the world around the Melvilles takes on a new and modern perspective, the family at Ellinghurst stays caught up in their loss, their ideals and their pursuit for happiness in their shattered world. Left alone in the world, after his mother’s death, Oskar too tries to make semblance of his life.

 …………..’It is so terribly hard for them, the ones who have passed,’Eleanor said. ‘They feel alive, you see, just as they always did. They have not changed their form or their character, only their vibrations. And yet they must watch their loved ones weep and weep for them as though they are gone for ever. It breaks their hearts.’………….( quoted from We That Are Left)

Clare’s narrative is deeply moving. Her figurative prose and masterful descriptions make this saga come to life. Every character reaches out and connects with the reader. The novel is well researched and paints a vivid picture transporting the reader back in time. While the story of Phyllis brings to light the great archaeological efforts of Egyptologist Howard Carter, Oskar’s narrative reverberates with the theories of Albert Einstein and Ernest Rutherford. Caught up with the changes around her, Jessica’s story is synonymous with that of many young girls, who first tasted freedom after the success of The Suffrage Movement in the 1920s.

The plot thickens as the pages turn, making it difficult to put the book down. Very deftly, Clare manages to incorporate the scientific theories  and political events from that period into the stories of the main characters. Their personal journeys are enthralling and  heart wrenching. One gets so engrossed in the lives of Oskar and the Melvilles, that even when the book finishes, it is difficult to stop thinking about them. Ellinghurst continues to haunt!!!!!

A very well researched and beautifully written piece of historical fiction!!!


About artikaaurorabakshi

Artika Aurora Bakshi Artika Aurora Bakshi is the author of three well-acclaimed children’s books,My Little Sikh Handbook, My Little Sikh Handbook 2: Ardas, My Little Sikh Handbook: Travel Journal, and an anthology of stories, Hold On To Me. Her first story, set in Amritsar, during the pre-Partition period, All She Had Left, was published on Story Mirror. She co-manages, a manuscript help and book review site. Her passion for reading has led her to helping other writers with their manuscripts. She comes from a family of lawyers and has a master’s degree in International Banking & Finance. Currently based in Sri Lanka, she teaches Commerce and History on a part-time basis at an international school and enjoys being part of the literary scene in Sri Lanka. A regular at the Galle Literary Festival and other literary events in Sri Lanka, Artika’s articles and book reviews have featured in the Daily Mirror, Daily News, The Ceylon Chronicle, and various blogs, such as,,, She was actively involved with SAARC Women’s Association of Sri Lanka and was President of the Association in 2016. An avid reader, Artika runs an online book club with a membership base of over 600 members. Her quotes are featured under soul.nightingale on Instagram and on Soul Nightingale by Artika Aurora Bakshi on Facebook. Artika is also working on her fourth children’s book in the My Little Sikh Handbook series and a second anthology of stories for adults. You can reach Artika at .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on November 1, 2015 by in Book Reviews, Fiction, Historical and tagged , .
%d bloggers like this: